Health, fitness and habits · Health
Clinical and preclinical obesity: the 2025 Lancet Commission definition and where BMI still fits

The tool for this guide: Open the BMI calculator
The 2025 Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology Commission defines obesity as excess body fat, then splits it in two. Clinical obesity is a chronic illness in which that fat has reduced the function of organs or tissues, or limits daily activities. Preclinical obesity is excess fat without either. BMI screens for excess fat but no longer decides the diagnosis alone.
What the Commission changed
The Commission changed what counts as the disease, not the way excess weight is measured. Its report, Definition and diagnostic criteria of clinical obesity, appeared in The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology in January 2025. A group of 58 experts agreed it through a Delphi consensus process, and Healio reports that 76 medical organisations endorsed it.
Before it, obesity was usually defined by one number: a BMI of 30 or more. The Commission starts instead from excess body fat, and then asks whether that fat is doing harm. That gives two conditions rather than one.
| Preclinical obesity | Clinical obesity | |
|---|---|---|
| Excess body fat | Yes | Yes |
| Organ or tissue function | No current dysfunction | Reduced or abnormal because of the fat |
| Daily activities | No limitation | Substantially limited because of the fat |
| What it is | A state of increased risk | A chronic, systemic illness |
| Aim of care | Reduce the risk of becoming ill | Treat the illness and the organ damage |
The wording of both definitions follows the Commission's report as summarised by Diabetes on the Net.
How an adult is diagnosed, step by step
The diagnosis has two stages: first confirm that there is excess body fat, then look for harm. Neither stage is done by a calculator.
| Step | What happens |
|---|---|
| 1. Screen | BMI is calculated as a quick surrogate for health risk, mainly for screening and for populations |
| 2. Confirm excess fat | BMI plus at least one other measure (waist circumference, waist-to-hip ratio or waist-to-height ratio), or at least two of those measures without BMI, or a direct fat measure such as DXA |
| 3. Exception | For a BMI above 40, no further measurement is needed to confirm excess fat |
| 4. Look for harm | A clinician assesses organ or tissue dysfunction and limits on daily activities |
| 5. Classify | Harm present: clinical obesity. No harm: preclinical obesity |
The exception in step 3 and the BMI role in step 1 come from the Diabetes on the Net summary; the three-route rule in step 2 is the one Healio prints. The organ-dysfunction criteria for step 4 are in Box 2 of the paper itself. This page does not reproduce them, because they are a clinician's checklist and a partial copy would be misleading.
Where BMI still fits
BMI keeps its job as the first, cheap look, and loses its job as the verdict. The Commission recommends it only as a surrogate for health risk at population level or for screening, because it cannot see where fat is carried, cannot separate fat from muscle and says nothing about whether any organ is affected.
That is why the second measure matters. Healio reports the waist-based cut-offs the paper gives for white adults: a waist circumference of 102 cm or more for men and 88 cm or more for women, a waist-to-hip ratio above 0.9 for men and 0.85 for women, and a waist-to-height ratio above 0.5. The paper sets thresholds by age, sex and ethnicity, and the numbers in this paragraph are not the ones for every group. For one example of why the BMI line itself moves between groups, see the BMI cut-offs guide for Asian adults. The waist-to-height line of 0.5 is explained in the waist-to-height ratio guide.
A common mix-up: obesity is not a BMI of 30 any more
The popular summary "BMI is dead" is wrong, and so is "30 still defines obesity". The Commission keeps BMI as the way in and does not replace the WHO's 30 as a screening point. What it removes is the idea that BMI alone confirms the condition, in either direction: BMI cannot tell fat from muscle or show where fat sits, so the same number can mean different things in different bodies.
It also separates being above a line from being ill. Someone can have excess fat and be preclinical, which the Commission treats as a state needing monitoring and risk reduction, not as an illness. Someone else can be diagnosed with clinical obesity because of how organs are working, a distinction no weight-and-height number can draw.
What preclinical obesity means for care
Preclinical obesity is usually not urgent, but it is not nothing. The Commission's aim for it is to prevent clinical obesity and other obesity-related disease. For many people that means health counselling, monitoring and lifestyle management, with regular checks for type 2 diabetes and other related conditions. Drug treatment or surgery may be considered where it prevents progression, or where reducing fat is needed before transplantation, cancer treatment or orthopaedic surgery. These points follow the Diabetes on the Net summary of the report.
Clinical obesity, by contrast, is treated as an illness in its own right. The Commission's care recommendations for it are in the paper and are not summarised here.
What has not changed, and what is still open
This is a consensus statement, not a law, and it has not been taken up everywhere. The Diabetes on the Net summary notes that it is not yet in UK guidance and differs from NICE's guideline NG246, including in the BMI thresholds used with waist measures. It also lists limits the authors accept: the need for clinician training, longer consultations and new diagnostic codes, and gaps in the evidence. Healio notes that the report says more work is needed on children, and prints no paediatric thresholds.
The practical result for the person using a BMI calculator is small. The calculator still gives the same BMI and the same categories. What changes is how much weight to put on it: a BMI is the start of a conversation, not the end of one.
Scope of this page
This page explains what a published definition says. It is not medical advice and cannot say whether you have clinical or preclinical obesity, which needs a clinician, an examination and tests. The numbers above are as reported from the Commission's paper by the two sources named; check the paper itself for its full criteria, including the organ-dysfunction list, the ethnicity-specific cut-offs and the criteria for children.
Frequently asked questions
What is clinical obesity?
The 2025 Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology Commission defines clinical obesity as a chronic, systemic illness diagnosed when excess body fat has reduced the function of organs or tissues, or substantially limits daily activities. It is a state of illness caused by the fat, not a measurement. A doctor diagnoses it from signs, symptoms and tests.
What is preclinical obesity?
Preclinical obesity is excess body fat with no current organ dysfunction and no limit on daily activities. The Commission treats it as a state of increased risk for later illness, not as an illness yet. Its aim is to lower that risk, usually through counselling, monitoring and lifestyle management.
Does the new definition mean BMI is no longer used?
No. BMI stays as a quick, cheap screening measure, but the Commission says it should not be used alone to diagnose obesity in adults. A diagnosis needs another measure of excess fat, such as waist circumference or waist-to-height ratio, or a direct body-fat scan. The one exception reported is a BMI above 40.
How is obesity diagnosed in adults under the Commission's criteria?
First excess body fat is confirmed: BMI plus at least one other measure such as waist circumference, at least two such measures without BMI, or a direct scan like DXA. Then a clinician looks for organ or tissue dysfunction, or limits on daily activities, to decide between clinical and preclinical obesity.
Is a BMI of 30 still the line for obesity?
30 is still the WHO's BMI threshold for adults of European ancestry, and BMI calculators still use it. The Commission does not retire that number as a screening point, but says BMI alone cannot confirm excess fat or show whether the fat is harming health. Some groups have lower or different BMI cut-offs.
Has the NHS or NICE adopted the clinical obesity definition?
Not as of the sources read for this page. A 2025 summary in Diabetes on the Net says the Commission's approach is not yet part of UK guidance and differs from NICE guideline NG246, including the BMI thresholds used with waist measures. Check NICE and your own health service for current guidance.
Who wrote the Lancet Commission report, and who backs it?
It was produced by a Commission of 58 global experts, led by Francesco Rubino, using a Delphi consensus process, and published in The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology in January 2025. Healio reports that 76 medical organisations have endorsed it. The Commission itself lists gaps in the evidence and areas needing more research.
People also search for
More in health, fitness and habits
What is a good CPS in Minecraft? 1.8 versus the 1.9 cooldownWhy 1.9 and later reward timing over click speed, the cooldown of each weapon, and damage per second at each click rate worked from the game's own numbers.Published · 6 min read
BMI and IVF on the NHS: 19 to 30, 19 to 29.9 and the partner's limit, ICB by ICBEach ICB sets its own BMI rule for NHS-funded IVF. Four policies read in full, why 29.9 and 30 are not the same, and what happens to the male partner's BMI.Published · 8 min read
4-7-8 breathing: the counts, how many cycles, and what is known about itFour in, seven held, eight out. Weil's own cap of four cycles for the first month, why the ratio matters more than the seconds, and what the trials measured.Published · 11 min read
BMI cut-offs for Asian and South Asian adults: 23 and 27.5, and where they come fromThe WHO never replaced 25 and 30. NICE now uses 23 and 27.5 for South Asian, Chinese and other groups, and a 2021 study of 1.5 million people found a different number for each group.Published · 7 min read
Push-up test norms by age and sex, and why the tables disagreeGood is 22 to 28 push-ups for a man in his twenties and 15 to 20 knee push-ups for a woman, on the Canadian test. The full table, the rules behind it, the Army's 2-minute version, and what the firefighter study can and cannot tell you.Published · 13 min read
Normal breathing rate by age, and how to count breaths per minuteA newborn breathes 25 to 60 times a minute and an adult 12 to 20. Ranges by age from the source, why charts disagree, the thresholds that mean fast breathing, and what a 15-second count does to the number.Published · 14 min read