Frequently asked questions

What is clinical obesity?

The 2025 Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology Commission defines clinical obesity as a chronic, systemic illness diagnosed when excess body fat has reduced the function of organs or tissues, or substantially limits daily activities. It is a state of illness caused by the fat, not a measurement. A doctor diagnoses it from signs, symptoms and tests.

What is preclinical obesity?

Preclinical obesity is excess body fat with no current organ dysfunction and no limit on daily activities. The Commission treats it as a state of increased risk for later illness, not as an illness yet. Its aim is to lower that risk, usually through counselling, monitoring and lifestyle management.

Does the new definition mean BMI is no longer used?

No. BMI stays as a quick, cheap screening measure, but the Commission says it should not be used alone to diagnose obesity in adults. A diagnosis needs another measure of excess fat, such as waist circumference or waist-to-height ratio, or a direct body-fat scan. The one exception reported is a BMI above 40.

How is obesity diagnosed in adults under the Commission's criteria?

First excess body fat is confirmed: BMI plus at least one other measure such as waist circumference, at least two such measures without BMI, or a direct scan like DXA. Then a clinician looks for organ or tissue dysfunction, or limits on daily activities, to decide between clinical and preclinical obesity.

Is a BMI of 30 still the line for obesity?

30 is still the WHO's BMI threshold for adults of European ancestry, and BMI calculators still use it. The Commission does not retire that number as a screening point, but says BMI alone cannot confirm excess fat or show whether the fat is harming health. Some groups have lower or different BMI cut-offs.

Has the NHS or NICE adopted the clinical obesity definition?

Not as of the sources read for this page. A 2025 summary in Diabetes on the Net says the Commission's approach is not yet part of UK guidance and differs from NICE guideline NG246, including the BMI thresholds used with waist measures. Check NICE and your own health service for current guidance.

Who wrote the Lancet Commission report, and who backs it?

It was produced by a Commission of 58 global experts, led by Francesco Rubino, using a Delphi consensus process, and published in The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology in January 2025. Healio reports that 76 medical organisations have endorsed it. The Commission itself lists gaps in the evidence and areas needing more research.

People also search for

More in health, fitness and habits

All 13 guides in health, fitness and habits · every topic

Find your BMI, knowing what it can and cannot say

The BMI calculator gives the standard categories and a weight range at your height. It is the screening step only; it cannot say whether excess weight is affecting your health.